(http://i54.tinypic.com/212dcid.jpg)
Pros
The first Android tablet with Google's tablet-specific Honeycomb OS. Fast. Beautiful, highly responsive touch screen. HDMI output for televison/computer monitor viewing.
Cons
User interface seems overcomplicated at times. While promised in the future, there's no support for Flash video or SD cards at launch. Android Market on the device is buggy. Few high-quality, must-have Honeycomb apps.
Bottom Line
The Motorola Xoom for Verizon Wireless is the best Android tablet yet, but with a lack of key features (like Flash video and SD card slot support) and mediocre apps at launch, it doesn't measure up to the Apple iPad.
As the first Android 3.0 device, the Motorola Xoom is a showcase for Google's tablet-focused Honeycomb OS. Starting at $599.99 (with a Verizon Wireless contract), the Xoom is priced to compete with the Apple iPad ($499-$829, 4 stars). In theory at least, there isn't much the iPad can do that the Xoom can't. Add a camera to mix, and the Xoom seems to edge ahead of Apple's tablet—but not so fast. Its support for Adobe Flash—the most enticing advantage over the iPad—isn't ready yet. Also, the Android Market's functionality on the Xoom is buggy at times, and the selection of apps doesn't come anywhere near what you'll find in Apple's App Store. Meanwhile, Apple's second-generation iPad is right around the corner, and it'll likely integrate that missing camera (but probably not Flash support). As it stands, however, the Xoom is the best Android tablet available right now, but this early in the tablet game, that doesn't necessarily mean you should buy it.
Before we get to the good stuff, let's get the pricing out of the way: The Xoom is available for $599.99 with a two-year agreement from Verizon Wireless. The monthly charge for 3G service is $20 for up to 1GB of data. And both Verizon and Motorola promise that the Xoom will be compatible with Verizon's 4G LTE network in the future. While 4G upgrades will be free, Motorola reps were unsure as to the logistics of the actual upgrade, or when it would occur. The Xoom pricing may seem steep, but it's very similar to the cost of a two-year AT&T contract on the iPad—see our tablet price comparison to dig deeper. For those who want the Xoom, but don't want to commit to a two-year contract, the tablet will cost $799.99. Motorola has announced a Wi-Fi-only Xoom is coming, but no release date has been confirmed.
Design
(http://i55.tinypic.com/24o3fc2.jpg) (http://www.windows7newsinfo.com/smf/index.php/topic,15453.0.html)
Measuring 9.8 by 6.6 by 0.5 inches, the 1.6-pound Motorola Xoom looks slightly different than its primary competitor, the Apple iPad. Where the iPad has a brushed metallic border and back panel, the Xoom's contour back is black matte plastic. There's no physical Home button, like on the iPad, and the Xoom has a front-facing 2-megapixel camera lens flanked by the Motorola and Verizon logos, which run along the top horizontal border of the front panel. On-screen Back, Home, and Active Apps buttons, and a small battery indicator light live below the 10.1-inch, 16:9 1,280-by-800-pixel touch screen. On the lower horizontal side panel, there are connections for a microUSB sync cable (which is included), HDMI output, and the proprietary power adapter connection. (The tablet doesn't charge via the sync cable like most devices.) Two Volume Control buttons are situated on the left vertical panel. Around back there are built-in stereo speakers, a rear-facing 5-megapixel camera lens, a dual LED camera flash, and the Power/Lock button—which seems like an odd placement choice. You'll also find additional Google, Motorola, and Verizon logos on the tablet's back panel.
It's worth mentioning that, side by side, the iPad and Xoom take up similar amounts of space—though the Xoom is not quite as wide and slightly longer. Also, both tablets weigh about the same. The Samsung Galaxy Tab ($399.99, 3.5 stars) is dwarfed by both devices (it has a far smaller 7-inch screen), but Samsung has plans for a larger Galaxy Tab that runs Honeycomb, so the Xoom may soon have Honeycomb competition.
(http://i56.tinypic.com/os51qc.jpg)
The oddest thing about the Xoom's design is what's missing: The microSD card slot, which sits next to the SIM tray (for future 4G support) behind a rubber cover on the top panel, is not enabled—Motorola confirmed that it is currently unusable. Of course, the iPad has no microSD slot at all, but until Motorola enables it, the Xoom doesn't really have one either. It's a strange practice to ship devices when they are not 100 percent ready, but it's not entirely uncommon—and we'll tackle the most egregious omission (no support for Flash) later in the review.
The Xoom integrates 802.11n Wi-Fi, is Bluetooth 2.1 +EDR HID compatible and sports 32GB of internal storage and a dual-core 1GHz Nvidia Tegra 2 processor. It is only the second tablet thus far to feature the Tegra 2, which is optimized to deliver the high performance necessary for a multitasking tablet with an HD screen. The Dell Streak 7 ($199.99, 2.5 stars) was the first Tegra 2 tablet to hit stores, but didn't ship with the Honeycomb OS. Our suite of Android Benchmark tests showcased the Xoom's prowess. It's significantly more capable than the Samsung Galaxy Tab, from the speed at which it calculates Pi to handling multitasking and complex graphics. The upload and download speeds and benchmark test results were, not surprisingly, similar to those of the Tegra 2-based Dell Streak 7.
Honeycomb: The New Face of Android
Android and its preloaded apps get a facelift in version 3.0. The lower horizontal bar for Honeycomb has a Back button that takes you to previous screen, a Home button, and a Multitasking button—simply tap it and every Web site, app, or game you have open will appear in a vertical, scrollable slideshow of windows. Tapping any of them takes you immediately to that app or site. While iOS generally just shows you icons for the apps you have open in its multitask bar, the windows presented in Honeycomb are snapshots of the actual app or site, which is nice. The right-hand portion of the horizontal bar houses your notifications—for e-mails, calendar events, download completions, etc.—as well as the time of day, 3G and Wi-Fi signal, and battery life indicators.
The upper left-hand corner of the screen houses a Google search icon, which complets real-time searches of the Web and the content on your device. Type in "D-U-N" and Dungeon Defenders immediately appears off to the side as an app you can jump to, while Google Web search options, like "Dungeons and Dragons" appear in a list below. It's super-fast and should be outlawed at any respectable bar's Trivia Night. Next to search, there's a microphone icon for Google Speak. With zero set-up, it works well. Say "Arnold Schwarzenegger" and you're immediately transported to Google search results. When I tried to trick the Xoom by quoting a Schwarzenegger movie line with my best attempt at his accent, it was only partially baffled: "Did you mean: 'get your ass to mars?'" Yes, I did.
Alongside the Apps icon in the upper right corner, there's a plus sign icon—tap it and you see the Xoom's various features broken down into sub-menus: Widgets, App Shortcuts, Wallpapers, and More. This button seems unnecessary when almost all of these things can be turned up quickly in other ways, but it's small and is tucked into the corner. You can also peruse all of your Apps and widgets by sliding your finger across the various customizable pages of the Home screen.
Apps and Android Market
The preloaded apps, games, and widgets on the Xoom are kept to a merciful minimum: Adobe Reader, Books, Browser, Calculator, Calendar, Camera, Clock, Contacts, Cordy (a game), Downloads, Dungeon Defenders (game again), E-mail, Fring (video calling), Gallery, Gmail, Google Search, Latitude, Maps, Market, Movie Studio, Music, Navigation, Places, Settings, Talk, Voice Search, and YouTube. All of the apps and widgets reside in the Apps menu, which you access by tapping on the icon in the upper right-hand corner of the home screen. They can also be moved to fill your home screen—you can pick and choose which you want to be there, and arrange them by holding your finger over an app's icon until it's highlighted, and dragging it where you wish.
We were able to peruse some Honeycomb-optimized apps, here are some of our favorites so far. The Body app, which was showcased at the Honeycomb announcement was fun to play with, but its graphics don't seem as awe-inspiring as apps we've seen on the iPad, like The Elements, the interactive Periodic Table. Regardless, it is still an entertaining app, and many of the Honeycomb-ready apps were in preview mode, so it's hard to know if some of the underwhelming graphics in Body, for instance, were the result of a beta version or not. Games, like the preloaded Dungeon Defenders, and the free Angry Birds, look fantastic on the bright, crisp high-def screen. Places looks fantastic—it's a simple update to the Google Maps app most of us are familiar with by now. When you zoom in closely, buildings become three-dimensional. Furthermore, businesses inside the building appear suddenly—searching the Empire State Building closely reveals various small businesses and tourism agencies housed within the building's 102 floors.
The Books app looks and operates quite similarly to Apple's iBooks app—full of realistic page-turn graphics, and pleasing illustrations and fonts. Prices range from $3.99 to $9.99 generally, with some premium titles, like Ken Follett's Fall of Giants priced at $19.99. And, of course, there are free books, as well.
Google Talk worked like a charm, with the 2-megapixel front-facing camera providing steady, reasonable-quality footage for video chats. I was able to hold a video chat with one friend who was on his Gmail account on a computer and a regular non-video chat with another friend simultaneously. Whenever I responded to the non-video chat partner, my video feed to my friend would pause on the other chat, but neither conversation was ever terminated. Talk was as easy to use as Apple's FaceTime—and because it works across multiple platforms via Gmail, it has the potential for a much wider user base than FaceTime's Apple-only world.
As for the Market itself, the good news is that downloading apps is an incredibly quick, intuitive, and streamlined process. It looks clean and is easy to navigate—with Apps for Tablets highlighted up top. The bad news is that there aren't many apps optimized for Honeycomb yet. Even though it's listed as a free app for tablets, download Conan O'Brien's Team Coco app and it looks borderline-horrible on the Xoom. Everything from the resolution of videos to the navigation menu looks bad, as it was designed for a smaller screen and an older version of Android. This is common throughout the Market's apps. Apple's solution to apps that were designed for iPhone but loaded on to an iPad was far more elegant—tap to zoom in, knowing that everything will look less sharp, or choose to view the app at its original size. The Android Market is chock full of apps that will offer a disappointing experience on the Xoom; here's hoping developers start developing for Honeycomb, and the Market is soon populated with more palatable stuff.
Despite being easy to navigate, the Market and Xoom suffer communication issues at times, as well. Occasionally, the Market was unable to load any search results for apps—no matter how obvious. The app itself did not crash, but its ability to properly search went kaput. Rebooting the Xoom fixed this issue the two times it occurred during my tests.
E-Mail, Music, Videos, and Photos (http://www.windows7newsinfo.com/smf/index.php/topic,15453.0.html)
Upon powering up the device, you're required to enter your Google account info—or create an account. From this moment on, your Gmail is synced to the Xoom. You can also sync your corporate e-mail account via Microsoft Exchange and new messages—as well as calendar notifications—will push to the Xoom's desktop. Gmail, of course, is best experienced via the dedicated app—leave the E-Mail app for your corporate or other accounts. Both apps push to the desktop, and the icons even differ slightly (one is the Gmail logo envelope, one is a generic-looking envelope).
The completely revamped music app looks similar, if less graphically impressive, to Apple's CoverFlow (notably, CoverFlow is absent on the iPad), moving albums from one corner of the screen to another when you drag your finger across your records. Tapping an album brings up the artist and song information, and everything works pretty effortlessly.
The Gallery is slightly revamped, but those familiar with previous Android iterations will recognize the basic layout. Photo albums are organized by thumbnails, and images look excellent on the high-res 24-bit display, as do videos, which are lumped in with photos in the gallery, as usual.
Movie Studio is a new app for video editing—it pulls from your loaded video collection and videos you shoot with the built-in camera. You can edit video you shoot using the Camera app here—and the recording quality is vastly superior to the Dell Streak 7's. Editing in Movie Studio is not quite as intuitive as using iMovie, but you eventually get the hang of it.
Still images taken with the 5-megapixel rear-facing camera get the benefit of a built-in, dual LED flash. Most of the images I took looked better without the flash, but it's still a useful tool in darker scenarios. The camera offers autofocus; auto, on, and off settings for the flash; and several scene modes and color effects.
As far as file support, the Xoom can handle AAC, AAC+, AMR NB, AMR WB, MP3, and XMF for audio; MPEG4 and 3GP for video, and GIF, JPEG, and PNG for photos.
Browser and Conclusions
The Browser app, at least for now, is the major shortcoming of the Xoom. It currently offers no Flash, and although Adobe promises support within three weeks or so, the consumer tech world—and the mobile world, in particular—is riddled with promises for upgrades and updates that go unfulfilled for far too long. Flash support is the primary differentiator between Honeycomb and Apple's iOS. True support would mean a more complete mobile Internet experience, with Web sites that feature flash animation or video that loads easily and properly. That this much-hyped support is not included at launch is pretty ridiculous.
The Browser now has tabs across the top, as well as visual bookmarks à la Chrome, and a status bar with quick buttons for bookmarking, searching, refreshing, or moving forward/backward. One major annoyance: many sites load as simplified mobile versions. The problem has a workaround: you can scroll to the very bottom of most mobile sites and tap on a link to the full site. When we did this, ESPN's mobile site made way for the full Web page we wanted in the first place, but this is 2011 and browsers should default to the site version most appropriate for the device they're loading on. Both Apple and Google could stand to work on this. Pinching and expanding to open articles is a familiar experience, and you can zoom in on text, then double tab the screen to have it wrap to fit the screen. If Flash truly does enter the equation, the browser will be a far more exciting app.
The Motorola Xoom has tremendous potential, so it's disappointing to see it lacking key features out of the gate. Organizing the release of a device among three companies (Motorola, Verizon, and Google) is complicated enough—throw in Adobe's Flash support, and it's no surprise that things are missing. While we want to extend the benefit of the doubt to Motorola that Xoom will indeed have Flash support and a working microSD slot, we have to review the device given to us—the same tablet you'll get if you buy one today. The Xoom is beautiful, with an intuitive user interface, excellent screen quality, and some very useful apps and features, like Talk and the dual cameras with a built-in flash. Whether the Android Market will catch up to Honeycomb, however, also remains to be seen. We'll revisit this review—and the Xoom's rating—when Flash and SD support are added. Until then, the Xoom is the best Android tablet available, but has plenty of room for improvement, and it's no match for even last year's iPad, much less the looming next-generation Apple tablet.