Author Topic: SSD's - Mere Hype or ?  (Read 2174 times)

Offline incurablegeek

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 91
SSD's - Mere Hype or ?
« on: September 27, 2010, 05:30:13 AM »

This evening I have been reading about SSD's. Whether or not to load only the OS, the OS and the Programs, or the Programs on a separate HD and the OS only on the SSD.

Why?  From what I have read, the performance of SSD's degrades badly over time, with the only way to restore it to its pristine state is to constantly reinstall your OS and Programs. Every time you write to an SSD space is allocated, space that cannot be regained by simply deleting what has been written. A very helpful article explaining all this is http://www.anandtech.com/show/2738/8.  There is much else on the net, but these articles by Anand Lal Shimpi appear to be definitive. His only recommendation for an SSD is the Intel 80 GB X25M Mainstream SATA II Solid-State Drive (SSD)


In Anand's words:
Quote
What have I gotten myself into? The SSD Anthology I wrote back in March was read over 2 million times. Microsoft linked it, Wikipedia linked it, my esteemed colleagues in the press linked it, Linus freakin Torvalds linked it.

SSD Anthology: http://www.anandtech.com/show/2738

I personally think this is a terribly interesting and rather relevant topic. I am sincerely hoping that those more experienced than I will venture their own opinions and experience. I do, however, reserve the right to "cross-examine".  ;)

Offline javajolt

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 36146
  • Gender: Male
  • I Do Windows
    • windows10newsinfo.com
Re: SSD's - Mere Hype or ?
« Reply #1 on: September 27, 2010, 05:55:46 AM »
SSDs are so new that we will not see real-world lifespans and reliability tests for a good bit. I would hope that they would be better than HDD but you never know.

SSDs are more reliable than hard disks, and should last a good 20 years at least not counting performance degradation.  If you're looking towards and SSD to be comprable to regualar HDD, odds are no. Are they fast and oh so wonderful? Yes. But if you're looking to buy an SSD now and hope for reliability, I'm afraid their track record isn't so good for now. Give them a few quarters/years and SSDs will eventually replace the old platter hard drives, but it won't happen for a while.

The answer to your other question of similar reliability level among SSD manufacturers is a resounding "No!". SSD manufacturers find various ways to cut costs by using cheaper NAND chips, controllers, QC process. Go for brand names like OCZ, Intel and Samsung - they are so far considered the most reliable on the SSD list.

SSDs are shock proof which itself puts them lightyears ahead of any platter hard disk.

Here's a statistic for the average lifespan of various data storage media:

platter hard disks: 3-6 yrs

magnetic tape: 10-20 yrs

floppy disks: 1-5 years (sometimes only a matter of hours  :) )

optical disks: 10-100 yrs

static memory (such as SSDs): 50-100 yrs

stone tablets: up to 10.000 yrs


Offline incurablegeek

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 91
Re: SSD's - Mere Hype or ?
« Reply #2 on: September 27, 2010, 07:10:11 PM »

According to Anand, (and his clear articulation of the strengths, weaknesses and anatomy of SSD's is extremely useful),

Quote
A single NAND flash die is subdivided into blocks. The typical case these days is that each block is 512KB in size. Each block is further subdivided into pages, with the typical page size these days being 4KB.

Now you can read and write to individual pages, so long as they are empty. However once a page has been written, it can’t be overwritten, it must be erased first before you can write to it again. And therein lies the problem, the smallest structure you can erase in a NAND flash device today is a block. Once more, you can read/write 4KB at a time, but you can only erase 512KB at a time.

It gets worse. Every time you erase a block, you reduce the lifespan of the flash. Standard MLC NAND flash can only be erased 10,000 times before it goes bad and stops storing data.

Based on what I’ve just told you there are two things you don’t want to do when writing to flash: 1) you don’t want to overwrite data, and 2) you don’t want to erase data.

From what I understand SSD's will last and function as long as JavaJolt's stone tablets, if and only if you only read from them. My question: I would assume that if you load only the OS on the SSD and the programs on a separate hard drive, the life and the performance of your SSD would be maximized.  ???