Author Topic: Where XP And Vista Kick Windows 7’s Butt 2 of 2  (Read 1615 times)

Offline javajolt

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 36142
  • Gender: Male
  • I Do Windows
    • windows10newsinfo.com
Where XP And Vista Kick Windows 7’s Butt 2 of 2
« on: June 30, 2009, 04:16:36 AM »
Performance, gaming, security, networking and entertainment. Don’t assume Windows 7 is always best. Sometimes the older OSes are winners.

Mobility



Laptops never quite have the processing power of their desktop cousins, so the relatively lightweight Windows XP seems an obvious pick for your mobile computing needs. It should deliver reasonable performance, even on old or budget systems.

What you won’t get by running XP on your laptop is any kind of sophisticated power management, which in theory should have an adverse impact on your battery life. As ever, though, it’s not quite as simple as that. Yes, Windows Vista can tweak your wireless adaptor, PCI Express bus, USB suspend options and more to reduce overall power consumption, but a large number of users still report that their laptop’s battery life is significantly increased under XP. It seems that the increased CPU use from running Vista’s extra features will often cancel out any benefit from its power management controls. That’s been more than a little embarrassing for Microsoft, but at least the company has learned from the experience. Windows 7 takes a more in-depth approach.

The focus is now on idle time. The typical laptop will spend most of the time just idling while it’s waiting for something to do, so reducing the power consumption at this stage can make a real difference to battery life. With this in mind, Windows 7 makes considerable efforts to reduce repeated background activities in Windows, drivers and applications. In addition to this, Windows 7 services will often start only when they’re required (Bluetooth won’t be launched until a Bluetooth device is attached, for example). Best of all, a new core parking scheme turns off all but one CPU core when there’s little to do, saving a significant amount of power when you’re only performing simple tasks.

The end result, according to our informal tests, is that Windows 7 appears to deliver even longer battery life than XP. We can’t say that definitively yet – there are too many factors involved and our test group is too limited – but it’s looking promising, and we think it’s likely that the disappointments of Vista will be forgotten soon after Windows 7’s launch.

Once you’ve also taken into account its excellent performance, relatively low system requirements and the advantages of being able to use its simplified networking while you’re out and about, Windows 7 has to be the standout winner of our Mobility category. Windows XP takes a respectable second place for being handily lightweight, which makes it more than suitable for extensive on-the-go use. Meanwhile, Windows Vista’s performance issues and its selection of well-meaning but ineffective power saving features means that it comes trailing into a dismal third place once again.

Mobility - XP:4.5 Vista:3.5 Windows 7: 4

Entertainment



If you’re looking to create a specialist entertainment PC, Windows XP could be a reasonable choice. It demands little in the way of memory or CPU power, for example, so it will run well on the majority of older systems. Yet it’s still highly compatible with all the hardware you might need: TV tuner, wireless networking adaptor, memory card reader and so on.

There’s surprisingly little software support within XP, though, probably because Microsoft hived off most entertainment features into Windows Media Center (WMC). So if you want WMC-like functionality – such as the ability to watch and record TV, manage your music collection or browse your digital photos – then you’ll have to opt for a third-party tool. We recommend the free MediaPortal (www.team-mediaportal.com). It’s a remarkably powerful program, but be aware that it does occasionally throw up glitches.

Opt for Windows Vista instead and you’ll get Windows Media Center thrown in (with the Home Premium or Ultimate editions, anyway), and that makes a huge difference. Hardware manufacturers know that Media Center is the biggest player in the entertainment PC world right now, so they take a lot of care to ensure that their products are compatible. This means that you’re less likely to have codec problems. Vista extras such as improved networking connectivity, Windows DVD Maker and HD support in Movie Maker are welcome, too.

Windows 7 takes this a step further with improved support for HD displays, including the ability to calibrate a screen to ensure it’s accurately reproducing colours. It’s easier to share your media files around a home network, and the touch interface support makes sure that everything is easy to use (for those with touchscreen hardware, anyway).

However, we’d bet that your budget for an entertainment PC is limited and that you won’t want to experience the driver-related issues that Windows 7 is bound to throw up in its first few months. So, while Windows 7 is bound to be a future winner, it’s overkill at the moment.

Our entertainment pick right now, then, is Windows Vista. It runs reasonably well on budget PCs, any performance issues it has won’t be a big deal for an entertainment system (with the possible exception of network transfers) and there’s plenty of compatible software and hardware available.

Meanwhile, Windows 7 is the best pick if you’ve got lots of money to spend or a HD touchscreen to hand and don’t mind the occasional delay when you discover that your TV tuner (or some other piece of kit) doesn’t work quite as it should on the new system. If your budget is limited, opt for XP instead. Shop around and you can put together an excellent entertainment system for just a few pounds.

Entertainment - XP:3.5 Vista:4 Windows 7: 3

Reliability



Whatever else you want from an operating system, reliability is essential. Defining exactly what that means can be tricky, though, as there are many different factors to consider. A reliable operating system has to be well understood by developers, for instance, and here Windows XP is in its element. It’s mature, it’s built around classic Windows NT kernel technology and there are many development tools around to help produce quality applications.

Reliability also requires weak points to be addressed, however – and Windows Vista does implement some important new ideas. Windows XP, for example, allocates system memory for device drivers, file cache, kernel stacks and other requirements at boot time. If, say, it turns out that your drivers need more RAM later, then that’s just tough: they’ll have to do without, usually with catastrophic results. Vista can manage its system memory dynamically, freeing up RAM in one area when more is required elsewhere, reducing the chance of driver-related crashes.

Of course, a really buggy application is going to fall over at some point anyway, so a reliable operating system must also provide ways to track errors, diagnose problems and find out what’s going on. It’s here that Vista really wins out over XP. Crash data is saved, allowing you to view your system stability over time. A greatly improved Event Viewer is far more likely to identify the cause of your problems, and Windows can regularly check for new fixes that might prevent particular crashes.

Windows XP wins in terms of stability and maturity, then. But the majority of problems are caused by bugs in drivers and applications, not core Windows code, and so Vista’s superior error handling and reporting is extremely important. When you also factor in a selection of low-level changes, such as improved memory management and the ability to recover from failures like broken services or corrupt system files, then Vista (despite all its quirks) just scrapes into first place for this category. Our award is for a strictly limited time, though, as we’d anticipate Windows 7 moving swiftly into the top spot once its understandable teething problems are ironed out.

Reliability -XP:3 Vista:4.5 Windows 7:3

Conclusion

We’ve spent a long time poking, prodding and stress-testing these three operating systems, but it’s still remarkably difficult to pick the outright best of Windows XP and Vista. XP is mature, still current enough to be compatible with most recent hardware and software, and a good all-round performer. But Vista fights back with a much better feature-set, especially in key areas such as security and error handling. On balance, we prefer XP for basic systems and would move to Vista only as hardware needs demanded – but that’s a fine line to tread.

The good news is that you won’t have to spend long agonising over the whole ‘XP or Vista?’ decision, because Windows 7 generally outdoes them both. Microsoft really does appear to have learned its hard-taught lessons and, while it hasn’t fixed everything, the latest incarnation of Windows does show significant improvements over its predecessor – impressive for a pre-release version. The finished Windows 7 can only be better, and it should finally give long-standing XP fans a reason to upgrade.