Author Topic: The UI challenge: Windows 7 vs Mac OS X  (Read 1622 times)

Offline javajolt

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 36142
  • Gender: Male
  • I Do Windows
    • windows10newsinfo.com
The UI challenge: Windows 7 vs Mac OS X
« on: July 25, 2009, 01:11:11 AM »
Side by side: which is better?

The next 10 slides compare Windows 7 and Mac OS X Leopard user interfaces, noting which does a better job at what. Each slide shows the one I consider to be the winner; you can see the "loser" by clicking the hyperlink within the text description, which opens a separate window so you can see them side by side.



The Mac gives you immediate access to your drives and applications, while leaving the Desktop open, when you first start (as seen here). By comparison, Windows 7 starts up with almost nothing, which makes you work harder to get going

Starting up: Windows 7 is too spare

The Mac's folders provide more controls over file manipulation than does Windows 7, with greater configurability. And the Mac's ability to search by user-defined criteria at any time is unmatched (shown below). By comparison, Windows 7 provides few search options, and only before you start a search

File window: Mac OS provides more

The Mac's Dock provides easy access to your applications and open files, as well as to other resources (pictured). It previews all open content. The Windows 7 taskbar is improved, with previews of running apps' contents now added (but not functioning in beta); But it can't show both folders' file lists and apps' content previews simultaneously, as the Mac can.

Taskbar: Slightly more flexible on the Mac

Both Apple and Microsoft have made lightweight gadgets part of their OSes in recent years, and they work comparably. But Windows 7 lets gadgets coexist with other onscreen apps and windows (see for yourself below). Mac gadgets, by contrast, take up the whole screen and disappear as soon as you open anything else

Gadgets: Windows 7 integrates better

The System Preference application makes it easy to find, use, and switch among control panels, keeping everything organized (see image). Windows 7's control panels open lots of windows, cluttering your screen fast

Control panels: Mac OS is simpler

When you're in an app saving or opening a file, it's easy to rename, add, or otherwise do file-level work within the app in Windows 7 (see below image). Not so in Mac OS, where you must close the dialog boxes and switch to the Finder for most such actions

Folder actions: Windows 7 gives more control

Figuring out network status can be a bear, and Windows 7's new UI provides good visual feedback (see image). The Mac OS X uses simple status indicators but no overall view of the network connections

Network management: Windows 7 is more visual

Backing up data should be trivial, and the Mac's Time Machine makes backups and restores amazingly easy (below picture). Windows 7 uses a limited utility that has a command-line feel to it that few people are likely to use

Backup: Mac OS X wins big

File sharing requires setting multiple levels of permissions, which the Mac OS X presents in a straightforward, unified UI (see image). By contrast, Windows 7 separates its controls in two places, with lots of subdialog boxes to wander through

File sharing: Mac makes it easier

Windows 7 provides an uninstall utility for all your apps, for easy system management (imaged below). The Mac OS has no such facility, and most apps don't provide their own uninstallers, so it's easy to end up with lots of deadwood app files on your Mac.

Uninstall: The Mac OS forfeits


« Last Edit: July 25, 2009, 05:08:35 AM by javajolt »