Wouldn't it be great if money didn't matter? In that altogether salubrious scenario, picking a PC processor would be quick and painless. After all, Intel makes undeniably the best money-no-object chip known to man.
Run the Core i7 975 Extreme Edition through any imaginable battery of benchmarks and it will return superior results to every other CPU currently available every time. The slight snag is the 975's punitive pricing: it will lighten your wallet to the tune of nearly £800.
To that figure, you then have to add hundreds more for a motherboard, a hefty helping of system memory, a decent graphics card and various items of PC paraphernalia. It all mounts up very quickly. Back in the real world, therefore, money does matter.
In turn, that makes CPU selection rather more complicated. Even if you do stick with Intel, for example, there are currently no fewer than three distinct sockets to choose from, each supporting a small army of processor models. Plus with value for money in mind you'd be unwise to disregard AMD.
It may not be able to compete with Intel on raw computational horsepower at the moment, but AMD has pulled out the stops on pricing. It has some incredible bang for buck on offer. Of course, the age-old AMD or Intel question is just one of many conundrums facing the intrepid CPU buyer.
Increasingly one must choose between maximising operating frequencies or core counts. If you're on a budget, so the conventional wisdom goes, you can't have both. That certainly seems to be the case if you make a comparison of processor models based on advertised clockspeeds.
Throw overclocking into the mix, however, and the pecking order changes rapidly. There are some real giant-killer CPUs out there if you're willing to have a go yourself.
Back to the future
Next, there's the question of future-proofing. One of the PC's greatest strengths has always been its ability to reinvent itself through constant technological progress and innovation. Nevertheless, some CPUs and their associated sockets and platforms are longer for this world than others.
AMD has a better track record than Intel for maintaining both backward and forward compatibility when it comes to this area. This is the kind of detail that might just swing your decision when much else is equal. If we're talking platform comparisons, there are a number of further factors to consider.
At first glance, two processors might seem closely matched in terms of price and performance. But add the supporting platform to the equation and a yawning gap can appear. Motherboards compatible with Intel's latest CPUs, for example, are still quite pricey.
Likewise, a cheap Core i7 chip is a false economy if you can't afford enough triple-channel memory to do it justice. As ever, it's horses for courses. For that reason, we've reduced the bubbling mass of CPU models available to just four hard-boiled devices. Each represents a respective best in class in the categories of value, future-proofing and overclocking, with the fourth and final our all-round top chip.
Clocks vs cores
Let's put the thought of prizes to one side for now and attack the first major conundrum, that of clocks and cores. If you can't have the best of both, which should take preference?
On the one hand, not all application types are keeping pace with the reality of multi-core hardware. Web browsing and gaming are the two most obvious examples of software types that have remained at least somewhat resistant to multi-threading efforts. Until the challenge of coding such multi-threaded software is overcome, multi-core processors will not fulfil their potential.
On the other hand, there's no doubting that the PC industry as a whole has effectively bet the farm on threaded software and multicore processor architectures. Wind back the clock to around 2004 and it was becoming increasingly apparent that the clockspeed-centric approach to ever-greater performance had hit a wall, on top of which was a large neon sign flashing '4GHz'.
But if the quest for ever-higher clockspeeds had come unstuck, advancements in integrated circuit production technology were allowing engineers to squeeze ever larger numbers of transistors into computer silicon chips. The only way to make the most of these increasing transistor budgets and therefore keep performance moving forward was to add more cores.
Thus we had what Intel now calls its 'right-hand turn'; the industry changed tack in favour of the current multi-core architectures.
The reign of multi-core
Most computationally demanding applications, including image rendering and media encoding, are already highly threaded and multi-core friendly. That will only become truer in future. Indeed, the more cores your CPU packs, the more you will find its performance potential is increasingly unlocked over the next few years as software developers hone their threading prowess.
Gaming is a good example here. Thanks to the recent release of Windows 7 and improved support in the new DirectX 11 API, games should be able to exploit multi-core chips much more effectively. What's more, the more cores you have, the better your PC will be for multi-tasking. These days, who doesn't have a plethora of apps running simultaneously?
As a general rule, then, we reckon the more cores and threads your processor can pony up the better. Consequently, quad-core is what you should be aiming for. That's especially true given that four cores can now be had for well under £100.
(1 Pound = 1.53922 USD)
Admittedly, AMD has confused the issue somewhat with its triple-core X3 processors. Indeed, in some instances, a triple-core processor with a healthy helping of cache memory will outperform a similarly priced quad-core processor with cut-down cache. But such scenarios will become rarer and rarer going forward.
The final and clinching argument is that while overclocking can be used to increase operating frequency, adding cores to your CPU tends to be much more difficult – if not always impossible.
Intel vs AMD
Now that we've established quad-core as the basic configuration of choice, should it be four Intel cores or four from AMD?
Well, Intel will currently sell you quad-core chips under the Core 2, Core i5 and Core i7 brands while AMD will supply you with both Phenom II and Athlon II CPUs in quad-core trim.
The easiest processor to discard is Intel's elderly Core 2. That's not because it's a weak performer or represents poor value – it's still a nice chip.
No, the problem is the aging LGA 775 socket that comes with it. It's a dead end and is soon to be killed off. If you already have an LGA 775 system and seek only to upgrade your CPU, the Core 2 is fine. But LGA 775 is a no-no for new PC builds. It has no future.
On the broader AMD vs Intel question, a large part of the answer comes down to cost. The more constrained your budget, the more AMD's processors make sense. The key point here is to look beyond the headline price of a given processor.
DECISIONS, DECISIONS: The decision of Intel over AMD is not as straightforward as you might think
You might, for instance, compare AMD's Phenom II X4 965 Black Edition chip to Intel's new Core i5 750, two processors that compete in the sub-£150 market. For the most part, this pairing delivers very similar performance, save for gaming where Intel has a clear edge. Add to that the fact that the Core i5 can occasionally be had for a few quid less and you might think that it's the obvious choice.
However, factor in motherboard prices and the winner is much less clear. Currently, only Intel's P55 chipset is compatible with the LGA 1156 socket required for Core i5 processors. You'll struggle to find a P55 motherboard for less than £80. By contrast, £45 is enough to secure a motherboard fit for the Phenom II.
Making matters worse for the Intel chip is the fact that it requires pricey DDR3 memory. For the AMD CPU you can opt for either DDR3 or cheaper DDR2 memory through your choice of the AM3 or AM2+ sockets respectively, both of which are compatible with Phenom II and Athlon II processors. This allows you to further cut costs, though you should remember that choosing the older AM2+ socket could limit your options for CPU upgrades in the future.
It wouldn't surprise us if AMD's upcoming six-core processor was only compatible with AM3 motherboards.
Choosing between sockets:
Intel makes things even tougher when it comes to choosing between sockets. With its new Core i5 and Core i7 family of processors it has introduced two incompatible sockets, LGA 1156 and LGA 1366. On paper, they form the basis of mainstream and high-end platforms respectively.
Unfortunately, Intel in its wisdom has chosen not to align its processor branding with the realities of the underlying hardware. So, while the Core i5 chip is indeed reserved for the LGA 1156 socket, Intel sells Core i7 chips in both formats, denoted in Intel's new product nomenclature as the Core i7 800 and 900 series respectively.
Significantly, these two flavours of Core i7 are distinctly different in terms of underlying architecture. Firstly, the 900 series chips and therefore all LGA 1366 boards sport a triple-channel memory interface. In other words, you have to have three rather than two sticks of DDR3 memory in order to achieve the maximum bandwidth.
Secondly, all chips on the LGA 1156 platform (that's all Core i5 processors and the Core i7 800 series CPUs) have 16-lane PCI Express controllers integrated into the processor die. Compared to the LGA 1366 platform – and indeed many AMD-based platforms, which often provide 32 or more lanes – this places a cap on the number of high-performance PCI Express peripherals, such as graphics cards, that can be attached.
For your average PC user that's hardly a crushing limitation, but it's worth bearing in mind should you wish to run multiple video cards or perhaps use a GPU as a general-purpose coprocessor in the future. Such high-end configurations will not necessarily be impossible, of course but there will certainly be some limitations that don't apply to those platforms that feature 32 or more PCI Express lanes.
The final issue concerns futureproofing and upgrade paths. LGA 1366 will be Intel's high-end socket for the foreseeable future. Early next year Intel will unleash its new six-core monster, codenamed Gulftown. It will only be available in LGA 1366 trim. Hence, with Intel platforms you can no longer buy a cheapish motherboard and drop in a high-end CPU later. You need to invest in the full platform.
Right now, however, there's actually remarkably little difference in terms of performance between the various Core i7 processors operating on the LGA 1156 and LGA 1366 sockets. In fact, thanks to an aggressive implementation of Intel's automatic overclocking feature (which is known as Turbo Boost), LGA 1156 can sometimes be faster.
In other words, unless you plan to upgrade to a six-core processor chip next year, there is probably little sense in paying extra for the pricier LGA 1366 processors and motherboards at the moment. Your current needs will be easily fulfilled by a processor on a cheaper LGA 1156 socket.
Prioritising features
Finally on Intel processors, it's worth noting that the lack of HyperThreading on the Core i5 700 series compromises performance in highly threaded apps by as much as 25 per cent.
HyperThreading is Intel's symmetric multi-threading technology. It allows a single core to crunch two software threads at the same time. Hence, quad-core Core i7 processors make eight logical processors available to a PC's OS.
HYPERTHREADING: The Core i7 has up to 8 cores available, four of which are virtual cores
As for AMD's Phenom II and Athlon II chips, there are fewer foibles to grapple with. Your choice essentially boils down to cores, clocks and cache memory. Both processor families are available in dual, triple, and quad-core configurations running at a wide range of clockspeeds.
Regarding cache memory, the key difference is level three (L3) cache: Phenom IIs have it, Athlon IIs don't. The lack of L3 cache hurts the Athlon II's performance compared to otherwise similar Phenom II chips to the tune of 10 to 15 per cent. It's significant, but certainly not a deal breaker.
That's because the underlying architectures of AMD's two key processor families are essentially the same. Combined with AMD's far more flexible platforms in terms of socket compatibility, it makes for a much more straightforward range of CPUs than Intel's increasingly baffling chips.
Overclocking issues
All of which leaves us with one final issue to address: overclocking. In the past, trying to squeeze extra performance out of a PC processor was not only dangerous but also often futile. For starters, processors and motherboards tended to lack fail-safe circuitry that protected them from the effects of running at increased frequencies and voltages. Torching your pricey processor was a genuine risk.
At the same time, the amount of headroom on offer was often rather modest. Five or six years ago, a 10 per cent overclock was a decent result. Today, all that has changed. Not only is overclocking much safer than before, the results can be truly spectacular. It's not unusual for Intel processors to overclock by as much as 1.5GHz. That kind of boost can translate into a huge performance increase of 50 per cent or more.
Intriguingly, however, it tends to be processors in the middle to lower order of any given processor family that offer the best results. Put simply, processor architectures usually have a frequency ceiling beyond which they won't operate. This applies almost regardless of their official operating speed.
For Intel's Core i7 chips, that limit is often around or just above the 4GHz mark. Take the Core i7 920 processor, for example. Officially it's a 2.66GHz chip and yours for around £200 – but when overclocked (using standard voltages), it's usually capable of stable frequencies of around 4GHz to 4.1GHz.
However, the 3.33GHz, £750 Core i7 975 only increases that headroom to 4.3GHz or so. That's over three times the price for a speed advantage of just five per cent.
Broadly speaking, AMD's chips tend to be a little less overclockable and top out at approximately 3.7GHz to 3.8GHz. However, the same philosophy applies. The higher up the chip range you go, the less headroom you get.
The lesson here is that if you are willing to dabble in a little overclocking, you can enjoy the very best processor performance either AMD or Intel can currently offer, but at a mere fraction of the price. That's got to be worth a try (1 Pound = 1.53922 USD)
-First published in PC Plus Issue 291